Jun 9, 2014

Ketchup on Hotdogs? YES!



There are many Chicagoan's who contend that you should never put ketchup on a hotdog. But I disagree.  I am Pro Choice - the hotdog aficiondo may use ketchup if she or he wants to. Different strokes for different folks.  If it feels good do it.  Don't let daChicaga Hotdog Fashionista's boss you around.

The Hotdog Police can't tell me what to do. And ketchup and pickle relish was defined as a vegetable by the Federal Government many years ago.





No Ketchup on Chicago Hotdogs a Cruel New Yawk Hoax

Chicagoan's have been victimized by a cruel hoax.  A New Yawker many many years ago started the "No Ketchup on Chicago Dawgs" as a joke to see how many Chicagoan's he could con into believing it. Sadly many Chicagoan's have been fished.


I learned some of the details of this diabolical plot in 1970 on Hill 327 near Danang, Vietnam. Out of

boredom Marines and Soldiers would take their tactical radios and turn to the top or bottom channel, then engage whoever had done the same thing into clever (and not so clever) repartee'.  Various racial insults, drug deals, proposed mini intramural wars, and general insults would follow.


One evening a fight developed between a soutsideaChicaga guy and a fellow from New Yawk.  Both had the accents made famous by their respective communities - they were colorful and entertaining but were not speaking the King's English. They traded insults about which city was superior - who had the baddest mafioso, the highest murder rate, who were the toughest, who had the best looking women, the best pizza, etc etc.


Eventually the discussion moved to hotdogs. The Chicaga guy opined about the great dogs in Chicaga, while the New York guy expounded on their great dogs. Each claimed superiority.

Then the New Yawker asked about Ketchup. The Chicaga guy proudly explained that no self respecting Chicagan would use ketchup on a hotdog.


The New Yawker laughed and then went into a long story where he stated that his grandfather had started the no ketchup for Chicago hotdogs as a rumor to fish gullible Chicagoans into believing. According to him this was well known in his family and that they enjoyed knowing that gramps had successfully conned Chicago. In Marine vernacular gramps had thrown out his line with the fishhook, and landed Chicago on the hook. Chicago was "hooked", "fished", and was not just a "guppy" but a "whale".


I have no idea if he was telling the truth but it sounded convincing.  You can look it up.


That is my story and I am sticking to it.

Please pass the Ketchup. 










  1. Chicago-style hot dog - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago-style_hot_dog

    Wikipedia
    Chicago-style hot dogChicago Dog, or Chicago Red Hot is an all-beef ... A number ofChicago hot dog vendors do not offer ketchup as a condiment.
  2. No ketchup on hot dogs - AmazingRibs.com

    amazingribs.com/.../hot_dogs.../no_ketchup_...

    AmazingRibs, Inc.
    But if you are over 18, never, ever, no how, no way, allow ketchup nowhere near a proper hot dog in Chicago. Fogeddaboudit. Apparently no less an authority ...
    More images for chicago ketchup hotdogs








  3. Ketchup on hot dogs? Go ahead, Chicago. It's OK. - Chicago ...

    articles.chicagotribune.com › ... › Love Affair

    Chicago Tribune
    Aug 3, 2011 - "No, I won't condemn anyone for putting ketchup on a hot dog. This is the land of the free. And if someone wants to put ketchup on a hot dog ...
  4. Why You Don't Put Ketchup On Chicago Hot Dogs: Chicagoist

    chicagoist.com/.../video_why_you_dont_put_ketchup_on_c.ph...

    Nov 26, 2012 - WBEZ's Curious City project attempted to answer the question, "Why is ketchup forbidden on Chicago-style hot dogs?" And the answer is...
  5. Why Chicagoans Don't Put Ketchup On Hot Dogs - Grub Street

    chicago.grubstreet.com/2011/08/why_chicagoans_dont_put_ketchu.html

    Aug 3, 2011 - Citing "foodie fascism," he claims that hating ketchup is a "matter of taste," and shouldn't be Chicago's "collective identity." He also explains that ...
  6. Absolutely, Positively No Ketchup On Hot Dogs. Never.

    www.huffingtonpost.com/craig.../ketchup-on-hot-dogs_b_928338.html

    Aug 19, 2011 - But if you are over 18, never, ever, no how, no way, allow ketchup anywhere near a proper hot dog in Chicago. Fogeddaboudit. Apparently no ...
  7. Why Does Ketchup on a Hot Dog Piss People Off? - Food ...

    www.chow.com/food.../why-does-ketchup-on-a-hot-dog-piss-people-off...

    Jul 13, 2012 - The real reason why ketchup on hot dogs bothers so many people who .... I am from Chicago, and I love the traditional Chicago Dog, but my all ...
  8. The ChicagoDog - Hot Dog Chicago Style - The Search for ...

    www.hotdogchicagostyle.com/chicagodog.php

    Chicago Style Hot Dog is more than just a Hot Dog; it's a taste sensation with the ...Chicago Hot Dog stands will not, as a rule, put ketchup on a Chicago Dog.
  9. Obama: 'You Shouldn't Put Ketchup On A Hot Dog' « CBS ...

    chicago.cbslocal.com/.../obama-you-shouldnt-put-ketchup-o...

    WBBM‑TV
    Jun 3, 2011 - President Barack Obama was born in Hawaii and didn't move to Chicago until he was 23 years old, but nevertheless, he proved Friday that he ...
  10. Never Put Ketchup On A Hot Dog: Bob Schwartz, Joe ...

    www.amazon.com/Never...Ketchup-Hot-Dog/.../09797892...

    Amazon.com
    Never Put Ketchup On A Hot Dog [Bob Schwartz, Joe Mantegna, Bob Sirott] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Travel through Chicago's ...

No comments:

Post a Comment